The Principal Financial Well-Being Indexsm Executive Summary - First Quarter 2004
Summary of Survey Findings
Workers Believe in Long-Term Investing
Methodology: The Principal Financial Group, the nation's 401(k) leader, commissioned
Harris Interactive® to conduct online research with employees (ages 18+)
of small and mid-sized U.S. businesses (firm size 10 - 1,000) about their attitudes
and perceptions regarding their financial well being. Harris Interactive conducted
The Principal Financial Well-Being Index survey of 1,235 employees online from
February 16-23, 2004. In theory, with a probability sample of this size, one
can say with 95% certainty that the results have a statistical precision of
± 3 percentage points; however, this online sample was not a probability
sample. "Propensity score" weighting was used to adjust for respondents'
propensity to be online. This is one in a series of quarterly studies to identify
and track changes in the workplace of small and mid-sized (growing) businesses.
The first Principal Financial Well-Being IndexSM survey was conducted in the
United States in 2000. In 2002, The Principal also began to conduct a Global
Financial Well Being Index.
Benefits Offered at Small and Mid-Sized Businesses (SMBs)
The top benefits offered at SMB firms are health insurance, defined contribution
retirement plans, life and disability insurance. When comparing over the same
period in the previous two years, there is a decreasing trend for health insurance,
and both defined contribution and defined benefit retirement plans. Table 1
demonstrates the trends.
TABLE 1
"What types of benefit programs (excluding vacation/holidays) does your
company currently offer you?"
Base: 1,235 U.S. Adults age 18+
| Company Sponsored Primary Benefits | 1 Qtr 2004 | 1 Qtr 2003 | 1 Qtr 2002 |
| Health Insurance | 90% | 92% | 94% |
| Defined Contribution Plans | 70% | 72% | 74% |
| Life Insurance | 69% | 68% | 74% |
| Disability Insurance | 52% | 52% | 55% |
| Defined Benefit Plans | 20% | 24% | 28% |
| Profit Sharing/Bonus | 27% | 26% | 26% |
| Stock Options | 11% | 12% | 9% |
| Free Parking | 60% | 57% | 63% |
| Tuition Reimbursement | 35% | 34% | 42% |
| Flex Time | 28% | 30% | 24% |
| Financial Planning | 11% | NA | NA |
| Personal Banking Services | 8% | 10% | NA |
| Legal Services | 9% | NA | NA |
| Executive Benefits | 4% | 4% | NA |
| Child Care Subsidies | 3% | 2% | 3% |
| On-site Day Care | 3% | 2% | 3% |
| Other | 8% | 8% | 9% |
- Significantly fewer employees of smaller firms (10 to 50 employees - 49%) are offered defined contribution retirement plans than employees of larger firms (51 to 1000 employees, 68-75%).
- Significantly fewer employees of smaller firms (10 to 50 employees - 81%) are offered health insurance than employees of larger firms (51 to 1000 employees, 89-95%).
- Significantly fewer employees of smaller firms (10 to 50 employees - 45%)
are offered life insurance than employees of larger firms (51 to 1000 employees,
62-82%).
Benefit Satisfaction
Upon identifying what benefits they are offered through their employers,
employees were asked to rate their satisfaction with some of the major benefits.
Employees are most satisfied with their retirement plans, defined benefit (46%)
and defined contribution (43%), and their life insurance plans (40%). Listed
in Table 2 are all the benefits, the percent of employees satisfied, and the
average rating.
- Employee satisfaction with health insurance is greater on average with larger
SMB firms (501-1000 employees, 6.6) than smaller firms (10-500 employees,
6.0).
TABLE 2
"Although you may have mentioned more than appear below, you indicated
that you have the following benefit program(s) through your company. Using a
scale from "1" to "10", where "1" means Not At
All Satisfied and "10" means Very Satisfied, please indicate how satisfied
you are with each benefit program."
Percentages included in chart represents those rating satisfaction as an 8,
9 or 10.
Base: U.S. Adults age 18+ varies by benefit offered
| Satisfaction with Benefit | 1 Qtr 2004 | 1 Qtr 2003 | 1 Qtr 2002 |
| Defined Benefit Plans (N=288) | 46% Average - 7.0 |
54% Average - 7.1 |
57% Average - 7.4 |
| Defined Contribution Plans (N=879) |
43% Average - 6.7 |
40% Average - 6.6 |
50% Average - 6.9 |
| Life Insurance (N=875) |
40% Average - 6.7 |
42% Average - 6.8 |
50% Average - 7.1 |
| Disability Insurance (N=647) |
38% Average - 6.6 |
42% Average - 6.8 |
47% Average - 6.9 |
| Profit Sharing/Bonus (N=299) |
38% Average - 6.5 |
38% Average - 6.4 |
38% Average - 6.4 |
| Health Insurance (N=1129) |
35% Average - 6.2 |
39% Average - 6.4 |
47% Average - 6.7 |
| Stock Options (N=112) | 32% Average - 5.8 |
44% Average - 6.8 |
30% Average - 5.9 |
Of those employees who are not currently provided all of the benefits they desire, the top noted benefits to add are defined benefit pension plan (22%), and profit sharing/bonus plans. Listed in Table 3 are the specifics, as well as the comparison to previous years.
TABLE 3
"Which one employee benefit do you most with that your company would offer
you?"
Base: 1,235 U.S. Adults age 18+
| Ranking | Benefits | 1 Qtr 2004 | 1 Qtr 2003 | 1 Qtr 2002 |
| 1 | Defined Benefit Pension Plan | 22% | 17% | 23% |
| 2 | Profit Sharing/Bonus Plan | 16% | 11% | 15% |
| 3 | Flex Time | 13% | 11% | 13% |
| 4 | Tuition Reimbursement | 8% | 9% | 7% |
| 5 | Defined Contribution Retirement Plan | 7% | 7% | 4% |
Benefit Importance
All employee respondents were asked to rate each benefit in terms of how important
is was to them on a 10-point scale with 10 being "Very Important."
As noted in Table 2, the levels of satisfaction are in a downward trend, however
the benefits are in an upward trend in importance. The top rated benefit in
terms of importance is health insurance (92%) and defined contribution retirement
plans (74%). Listed in Table 4 are a complete list of benefits, and a comparison
to the same period in 2003.
Life insurance is significantly more important on average to employees with
children in the household (7.6) than those without (7.2).
Disability insurance is significantly more important on average to employees
age 35 and above (7.7 to 8.0) than to employees age 18 to 34 (7.1).
TABLE 4
"Using a scale from "1" to "10", where "1"
means Not At All Important and "10" means Very Important, please indicate
how important each benefit program is to you."
Base: 1,235 U.S. Adults age 18+
| 1 Qtr 2004 | 1 Qtr 2003 | |
| Health Insurance | 92% Average - 9.3 |
88% Average - 9.2 |
| Defined Contribution Plans | 74% Average - 8.3 |
70% Average - 8.2 |
| Disability Insurance | 58% Average - 7.6 |
56% Average - 7.6 |
| Defined Benefit Plans | 59% Average - 7.5 |
57% Average - 7.5 |
| Life Insurance | 53% Average - 7.3 |
54% Average - 7.4 |
| Profit Sharing/Bonus | 47% Average - 6.7 |
41% Average - 6.5 |
| Stock Options | 20% Average - 4.8 |
18% Average - 4.6 |
Benefits for Recruit & Retention
SMB firms offer employee benefits to aid in the recruiting and retaining of
quality employees. To measure how employees react to the presence of good employee
benefits. Just over 70% said that good benefits encourages them to work harder
and perform better, and 60% said they would keep working for their current company.
See Table 5.
TABLE 5
"Please indicate the extent to which you agree or disagree with the following
statements
"
Base: 1,235 U.S. Adults age 18+
| Completely/ Somewhat Agree | Neither Agree/ Disagree | Completely/ Somewhat Disagree | |
| Having a good employee benefits plan encourages me to work harder and perform better. | 71% | 20% | 9% |
| Having a good employee benefits plan keeps me working for my current company. | 60% | 21% | 19% |
| My company is concerned about my long-term financial future. | 25% | 25% | 50% |
When looking back at how respondents over the past 4 years have responded to
this question - there is a an upward trend in the number of employees agreeing
with the statement that good benefits encourages them to work harder and perform
better. There is a decreasing trend with the number of employees agreeing with
the statement that a good employee benefits plan keeps them working for their
current company. See Table 6 for details.
- Employees of larger firms (500-1000 employees) agreed more to the statement 'good employee benefits plan keeps me working for my current company' on average (3.8) than those in smaller firms (10-500 employees) (3.4).
TABLE 6
"Please indicate the extent to which you agree or disagree with the following
statements
"
Base: 1,235 U.S. Adults age 18+
|
Trending Comparison (% of respondents agreeing completely or somewhat) |
1 Qtr 2004 | 1 Qtr 2003 | 2 Qtr 2002 | 1 Qtr 2001 |
| Having a good employee benefits plan encourages me to work harder and perform better. | 71% | 64% | 61% | 59% |
| Having a good employee benefits plan keeps me working for my current company. | 60% | 62% | 70% | 75% |
| My company is concerned about my long-term financial future. | 25% | 26% | 28% | 28% |
Employee Perception of Financial Well Being
In measuring employees' attitudes and perceptions about their financial well-being,
a series of different questions were asked of them. First they were asked to
identify how much they agreed with some statements relating to how concerned
they are about their long-term financial future and how happy they are about
their current well-being. According to Table 7, roughly 3 out of 4 employees
are very concerned about their long-term financial future and only 1 out of
3 employees are extremely happy with their current well-being.
TABLE 7
"Please indicate the extent to which you agree or disagree with the following
statements
"
Base: 1,235 U.S. Adults age 18+
| Agree (Rate 4, 5) | Neutral(Rate 3) | Disagree(Rate 1, 2) | Average on 5-pt scale | |
| I am very concerned about my long-term financial future. | 76% | 13% | 11% | 4.0 |
| I am extremely happy about my current financial well-being. | 34% | 21% | 45% | .2.8 |
TABLE 8
"Please indicate the extent to which you agree or disagree with the following
statements
"
Base: 1,235 U.S. Adults age 18+
| Completely/Somewhat Agree | 1 Qtr 2004 | 4 Qtr 2003 | 1 Qtr 2003 |
| I am very concerned about my long-term financial future. | 76% |
77% | 76% |
I am extremely happy about my current |
34% | 31% | 27% |
FINANCIAL OUTLOOK FOR 2004
SMB employees were asked to share their financial outlook for 2004, and the
just under half (48%) said they were very or somewhat optimistic. About 1 in
4 (27%) said their outlook was very or somewhat pessimistic. Chart 9 shows a
graphic representation.
- Significantly fewer employees with less than $35,000 in household income (26%) said they were optimistic about their outlook than employees with greater than $35,000 in household income (46%).
Chart 9 - Outlook for 2004
"Which of the following best describes your financial outlook for
the year 2004?"
Base: 1,235 U.S. Adults age 18+
| Very Optimistic |
10% | ![]() |
||
| Somewhat Optimistic | 38% | |||
| Neither | 25% | |||
| Somewhat Pessimistic | 21% | |||
| Very Pessimistic | 6% | |||
Job Security
Job security continues to top the importance chart when compared to long-term
financial future and challenging work. In the most recent study, 52% rated job
security as number one in importance to them followed by long-term financial
future and challenging work.
- The proportion of employees who rated job security as number on in importance was significantly higher for those with children in the household (57%) than those without (49%).
TABLE 10
"Please rank the following items in terms of how important it is to
you."
Base: 1,235 U.S. Adults age 18+
| Respondent Ranked Item #1 | 1 Qtr 2004 | 4 Qtr 2003 | 1 Qtr 2003 | 1 Qtr 2002 |
| Job Security |
52% |
48% |
49% |
50% |
| Long-Term Financial Future | 31% | 33% | 35% | 32% |
| Challenging Work | 17% | 19% | 16% | 17% |
Investment Changes
As the economy is in a fluctuating state, respondents were split into two random
groups. One group was asked an identify question to last year to allow tracking
of previous measures, and the second group was asked a question as to whether
they had moved their money to more stable or more volatile investments. See
Charts 11 and 12 below for details.
CHART 11
"Given the current stock market and economic conditions, have you
made changes in how you have your retirement savings invested - moving from
volatile
investments to more stable investments."
Base: 596 U.S. Adults age 18+
![]() |
1st Quarter 2004 Of those respondents with retirement savings, 34% have made changes in how their retirement savings are invested – 66% have not. N=596 Relatively unchanged from 1st Quarter 2003 – with 35% making changes
and 65% not. N=1,111 |
|||
CHART 12
"Given the current stock market and economic conditions, have you made
changes in how you have your retirement savings invested?" Base: 639 U.S.
Adults age 18+
![]() |
1st Quarter 2004 Of those respondents with retirement savings, 27% have made changes in how their retirement savings are invested – 19% moved to stable and 8% to volatile investments. N=639 |
|||
Satisfaction With Employer Sponsored Savings Tools
Employees were asked to rate how satisfied they are with their employer sponsored
benefit program in providing them with the tools they need to save for the future,
45% are very or somewhat satisfied - down from 4th quarter 2002. Table 13 shows
the details.
TABLE 13
"Overall, how satisfied are you with your employer sponsored benefit
program in providing you with the tools you need to save for your future?"
Base: 1,235 U.S. Adults age 18+
Total |
||
| 1 Qtr 2004 | 4 Qtr 2002 | |
| Satisfied (*net) | 45% | 54% |
| Neither Satisfied/Dissatisfied | 21% | 18% |
| Dissatisfied (*net) | 34% | 28% |
SECURE ABOUT FINANCIAL WELL-BEING
SMB employees were asked to describe how secure they felt about their financial
well-being in today's economy. Based on their feedback, less than 1 out of every
3 employees (30%) feel secure about their financial well-being in today's current
economy. Chart 1 depicts how employees rated their security levels.
Chart 14 - Security
Question - "Which of the following best describes how secure you feel about
your financial well-being in today's current economy?" Base: 1,235 U.S.
Adults age 18+
| Very Secure | 4% |
![]() |
||
| Somewhat Secure | 26% | |||
| Neither | 26% | |||
| Somewhat Insecure | 31% | |||
| Very Insecure | 13% | |||
CHANGE TO OVERALL SPENDING
SMB employees were asked to describe how the current economy has impacted their
overall spending in the past two months - 16% said they had increased their
overall spending versus 37% that said they had decreased their spending. Two
times as many said they had decreased their spending versus increased.
Chart 15 - Overall Spending
"Which of the following best describes how the current economy has impacted
your overall spending in the past two months?" Base: 1,235 U.S. Adults
age 18+
| Greatly increased | 4% |
![]() |
||
| Increased a little | 26% | |||
| About the same | 26% | |||
| Reduced a little | 31% | |||
| Greatly reduced | 13% | |||
2004 PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATES
According to SMB employees - George W. Bush and John Kerry tied with 25% noting
they would be the best at ensuring the availability of healthcare to all Americans.
Table 16 - Presidential
"Which of the following 2004 presidential candidates do you believe would
do the best at
"
Base: U.S. Adults age 18+
| 2004 Presidential Candidates |
…ensure availability of affordable healthcare to all Americans? |
| George W. Bush | 25% |
| John Kerry | 25% |
| Other Candidates |
11% |
| Not Sure | 39% |
| N=1,199 |
Harris Interactive® (www.harrisinteractive.com) is a worldwide market research and consulting firm best known for The Harris Poll®, and for pioneering the Internet method to conduct scientifically accurate market research. Headquartered in Rochester, New York, Harris Interactive combines proprietary methodologies and technology with expertise in predictive, custom and strategic research. The Company conducts international research from its U.S. offices and through wholly owned subsidiaries-London-based HI Europe (www.hieurope.com), Paris-based Novatris and Tokyo-based Harris Interactive Japan-as well as through the Harris Interactive Global Network of independent market- and opinion-research firms.





