An empty baseball field at sunset

October economic outlook: Why base hits matter in baseball and the economy

Quick takeaways

  • Some companies grab headlines for wild stock market gyrations. But they’re not really representative of the consistent progress that businesses both big and small try to achieve every day, year after year. So if you think one company predicts good or bad for the economy, you may want to reconsider.
  • The Federal Reserve continues to try to tame inflation. But it takes time, and there may be some economic effects, such as higher unemployment, with interest rate increases. Although history has some clues as to what the near future looks like, the exact mix of economic factors at play in 2022 means that the reality remains anyone’s guess.

In some ways, October can feel like an in-between month. The rush of summer subsides, back-to-school routines settle in for many, and the high-octane energy of the holidays hasn’t yet kicked in.

Unless, of course, you’re a baseball fan. Then, October marks a sprint of a different sort, especially for teams trying to cobble together enough wins to make it to the playoff finish line.

Sports continue to provide some interesting analogies for evaluating the 2022 economy. A lot of baseball teams are stuck not knowing what the future holds. And a lot of us are stuck not knowing exactly where the economy is headed. Several baseball teams will make a frantic dash to win as many games as they can, and many companies—after the mid-October release of third quarter data—may have to make a similar dash to adjust before year’s end.

Where will it all end up? It’s worth remembering that the fundamentals—to baseball, to the economy, to your financial situation—matter quite a lot.

What we can learn from baseball (and the movies)

Have you ever heard of sabermetrics? Maybe not. How about the movie Moneyball?

The latter, of course, was an acclaimed (albeit loose) adaptation of a book, Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game, that described the seemingly improbable run of the 2002 Oakland A’s. Lacking big stars and an expansive budget, the team made it to the first round of the playoffs not because of emotion-jolting home runs but because of sabermetrics.

The premise of sabermetrics is that one star player who hits a lot of home runs isn’t enough to push you to the top of the baseball heap. For that you need a team that gets on base all the time, even if none of the players is a regular home-run hitter. “For followers of sabermetrics, it doesn’t matter how you score, it matters that you score—slow, steady, fundamentally,” says Heather Winston, director of individual solutions at Principal®.

Sabermetrics equates to the economy like this: It’s not the one-day run (or fall) of the stock market or the flashy company with the meteoric stock rise—the equivalent of a home run—that represents its health. Meme stocks matter less than the collection of companies ensuring their balance sheets stay in the black while they service customer wants and needs. Declining jobless claims and blue-chip stocks are the equivalent of getting on base, every time, every year.

“Are there outliers to those stable, growing companies that have normal ups and downs? Of course,” Winston says. “But to have long-term success, it’s about consistency, time, and the benefit of time—getting on base.”


Are there outliers to those stable, growing companies that have normal ups and downs? Of course. But to have long-term success, it’s about consistency, time, and the benefit of time—getting on base.”

—Heather Winston, director of individual solutions at Principal


Unfortunately, October, like so many months this year, continues to generate a lot of mixed data—some pitches are home runs and some are strikes. Inflation remains stubborn, but lots of people are working and corporate profits continue to remain strong for many.1 When you’re looking for a clear message, this complicated data doesn’t help.

“As a public, we can be super swayed by the outrageous or the brash,” Winston says. “But it is rarely one lone data point that tells the story. We have to teach ourselves to look at numerous components, synthesize them, and then come up with conclusions. We cannot quickly interpret everything as a singular fact.”

Your wallet: Your retirement accounts’ progress has likely presented its own mixed messages based on your goals and asset allocation (mix of investments). But changing your long-term strategy as a response to a short-term headline may derail progress. “When it comes to financial security, some people may think there’s a faster way and swing for the fences, but that may be risk that’s unnecessary,” Winston says. Time in the market, not timing the market, remains true, even when there’s market volatility.

Why the multiplier effect matters

The idea of sabermetrics—getting on base over and over—matters quite a lot in the context of September’s big news-getter, the Federal Reserve’s decision to raise interest rates.

It’s the second large jump of the year, and rate increases are the biggest bat that the Fed has to try to beat back the inflation that continues to cause a lot of pocketbook distress. Just like the last time, the Fed’s move garnered lots of news headlines and varying rushes to judgment by pundits. But unless you’re in the market for a home mortgage or a car loan, or have a variable interest loan, that news probably didn’t cause you to do anything different.

“It’s good to stay up on economic news, but it’s also good to have a filter and understand, strategically, when you can ignore some things,” Winston says. “It’s like interjecting a pause in your thinking. Monetary policy, what the Fed is responsible for, doesn’t impact all of us in the same ways.”

The Fed’s decision wasn’t surprising; the board has been transparent about their focus—bringing inflation down. If you have those big-ticket, interest-dependent decisions on the horizon, you may need to adjust based on your financial goals. Taming inflation will take time, and we’re all impatient for the end positive result.

Your wallet: What’s your getting-on-base strategy—the thing you do for your financial security, over and over? “Those little actions have a multiplier effect over time,” Winston says. For example, consistently increasing your retirement savings—say, when you get a raise, or a percentage point every year—adds up dramatically. And it’s a retirement savings strategy that people use, over and over—because it works.

What's next?

  • Are you getting enough base hits for your retirement savings? Short-term changes can bolster your long-term retirement plan. Log in to your Principal account to set up yearly auto-increases or check in on your contribution rate. Don’t have an employer-sponsored retirement account? We can help you set up your own retirement savings.

1 Trading Economics

The views and opinions expressed are for informational and educational purposes only as of the date noted and should not be considered investment advice. No forecast based on the opinions expressed can be guaranteed and may be subject to change without notice. No investment strategy, such as diversification, can guarantee profit or protect against loss.

Investment advisory products offered through Principal Advised Services, LLC. Principal Advised Services is a member of the Principal Financial Group®, Des Moines, IA 50392.

Insurance products and plan administrative services provided through Principal Life Insurance Company®, Securities offered through Principal Securities, Inc., member SIPC and/or independent broker-dealers. Investment advisory products offered through Principal Advised Services, LLC.

© 2022 Principal Financial Services, Inc.